Here's the thing--even before the Brewers went out and got CC Sabathia (who apparently went on a punctuation diet when he switched leagues and lost the periods between his first initials), the Cubs were going to have to make a move for a solid pitcher. They were looking like they were going to make it through the season okay, but once you started looking at playoff matchups, things got a little scary. Back before the Diamondbacks fell to earth, plotting a pitching matchup against them looked scary. Brandon Webb versus Carlos Zambrano? Not bad for the Cubs, but no guarantee of a victory. Dan Haren versus Ryan Dempster? Ouch (though we all love the Demp). Ted Lilly versus Cub-slaughterer Randy Johnson? Okay, so Johnson only has a 5.18 ERA, but he's still scary against the Cubs. A repeat of the 2007 playoffs seemed all too plausible.
And then you look at the World Series. Boston throwing out Cub-killer Beckett (we still have nightmares about him from 2003), Matsuzaka, and Lester is also scary, and now we have to worry about the Rays (first time in my life I've ever written that sentence) since we saw what they did to us in Tampa Bay.
So we needed pitching. And then when the Brewers, who were surging anyway, went out and got Ben Sheets a co-ace, the Cubs really needed to do something. And they did. And while there's a big question mark in the trade, I'm happy to see the Cubs moving aggressively and getting someone who could be Zambrano's co-ace--leaving the Demp as ace-in-waiting.
Let's start with the downside. Murton could be an AL batting champion, Patterson has shown flashes, and Billy Beane is pretty good at picking up young pitchers, which means he thinks Gallagher is going to keep developing. They could all be All-Stars in a few years. Or not. But the thing is, the Cubs have seven All-Stars at the moment. How many does one team need?
The name I've seen brought up in connection with Harden is both hopeful and troubling--Mark Prior. Harden can dominate like Prior, but he can also spend time on the DL like him. While Sabathia is a horse, Harden seems more delicate--though he's made 11 straight starts at the moment. But does that mean he's healthy, or that he's getting ready to break down?
But in those 11 starts, he's 5-1 with a 2.34 ERA, and there's two shutouts buried in there. He's got 31 walks in 77 innings and is sitting on a 1.14 WHIP. Sabathia's walks are better--34 in 122 innings---but his WHIP's at 1.23 and his ERA is 3.83 (though a lot of that is due to his slow start). But then look at the Ks--an impressive 123 in 122 innings for Sabathia, but an eye-opening 92 in 77 innings for Harden. He can dominate.
But he's gotta stay healthy. It's a chance, but he seems healthy now, so we can hope, which is pretty much all we can ever do so we should be comfortable with it by now. And I should add that the Cubs got a decent bullpen arm as well--Chad Gaudin, with his 3.59 ERA. If you listen to conventional wisdom, a 3.59 ERA in the AL is worth about a 3.09 in the NL, so we'll see what Gaudin's got. At the moment, though, this is a trade that could help the Cubs more than Sabathia helps the Brewers, and from the perspective of the current moment, it looks like a good one.
Tuesday, July 8, 2008
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)